With a lack of major upsets during conference tournament week, the outlook for this year’s NCAA tournament has changed substantially. Nevertheless, there are some key questions that need to be answered.
How high will the committee seed the Ivy League teams?
Two highly entertaining Ivy League semifinals were a continuation of the regular season — tight matchups by talented teams. Yale then lifted the trophy by dominating Princeton.
Yale’s victory lifted the Bulldogs to 6th in the RPI, while Princeton held at No. 4. We project the these teams to be seeded 6th and 7th, respectively.
Should Stanford, Hopkins (and maybe JMU) get better looks at seeds?
James Madison, Johns Hopkins and Stanford occupy spots 9-11 in the RPI, and each have solid cases for inclusions as seeds over Maryland (No. 8 in the RPI). The Terrapins’ best wins are over JMU and Hopkins, and that’s where it’s hard to find a path for either of those teams to be seeded.
Stanford’s quality wins over Yale and Virginia are outpaced by losses to Army and Denver, both sub-20 RPI teams. Meanwhile, Hopkins also beat JMU, has a strength of schedule of 5 and its worst loss is to Michigan (RPI No. 19).
JMU has the key win over Florida and no other wins over a tournament team. It’s difficult to bump Maryland when looking at the data.
Who gets the final at-large spots?
This is a year of relatively weak at-large candidates on the bubble. With the one-bid leagues remaining truly singular bids, the teams on the bubble weren’t whittled like in the past. Let’s examine our candidates.
Duke (RPI 20, SOS 20)
Case for: A solid RPI and SOS plus wins over tournament team Clemson and bubble team Brown.
Case against: The Blue Devils also lost to that Clemson team, but it’s a very average profile (1-5 against the RPI top 20).
Verdict: In
Army (RPI 21, SOS 48)
Case for: Two quality wins over Stanford and Navy, a 4-3 record against the RPI top 40.
Case against: A low SOS, a loss to non-tournament team Colorado and possible injury questions.
Verdict: In
Dartmouth (RPI 22, SOS 22)
Case for: A solid RPI and SOS, a win over A-10 champion UMass and fellow bubble team Colorado.
Case against: Went 2-5 in the Ivy League to miss the tournament and lost to fellow bubble teams Brown and Harvard.
Verdict: Out
Drexel (RPI 23, SOS 47)
Case for: That 14-4 record is impressive and includes a win over Harvard, MAAC champion Fairfield and the Big Ten’s fourth-place team, Penn State.
Case against: A loss to sub-30 RPI team UConn, losing twice to Stony Brook and nearly the lowest SOS among teams in question.
Verdict: Out
Virginia Tech (RPI 25, SOS 8)
Case for: That win over Syracuse, the 8th-rated SOS.
Case against: A .500 record, a loss to High Point (RPI 55) and seven losses by nine-plus goals.
Verdict: Out
Harvard (RPI 26, SOS 29)
Case for: Wins over two NCAA teams (Penn, Navy) and five total against the RPI top 40.
Case against: Three losses to likely non-tournament teams (Drexel, Cornell, Notre Dame), missing the Ivy League tournament and losing to Brown
Verdict: Out, first team to miss
Brown (RPI 27, SOS 14)
Case for: A win over Yale, head-to-head victory over Harvard, a strong SOS (14th), made the Ivy League tournament and was very competitive even in its losses (Four of six losses by 2 or fewer goals).
Case against: Low RPI, only 1-5 against the RPI top 20 and a loss to non-tourney side Cornell.
Verdict: In, last team
Colorado (RPI 28, SOS 22)
Case for: Wins over CAA champion Stony Brook and bubble team Army.
Case against: Low RPI (28), a 3-8 record against the RPI top 40 including losses to bubble team Dartmouth and non-tournament teams Arizona State and USC.
Verdict: Out
If Brown is included, the Bears will have the fourth-highest RPI for any at-large selection. The past two seasons have seen Duke (RPI 31 in 2024) and Penn State (RPI 32 in 2023) be included, while Louisville got in with an RPI of 31 in 2017 when the field was still 26 teams.
Interestingly enough, no teams rated between 25 and 30 have been included in the NCAA tournament. Four teams with an RPI of 24 were granted at-large bids (2019 Stanford, 2016 Johns Hopkins, 2015 Louisville, 2013 Dartmouth).
Will the committee deviate from its geographic principles?
As it stands, the selection committee could make a bracket with only two flights (Stanford and Denver to Florida). Is this the best option for bracket integrity? Not at all, as it means Akron drives to play Michigan in Evanston and then Florida would likely face Stanford or Denver in the second round.
If the committee is granted the permission to add one or two more flights, the bracket will be more balanced than it’s currently constructed.
Notes: Records against the RPI top 20, top 21-40, significant wins and significant losses (over 40th) are based on performance against the current RPI rankings (all games included), not human polls. Conference champions are listed as automatic qualifier. For the 2025 season, 15 automatic qualifiers will be granted. No play-in games will take place in the 29-team field.
AUTOMATIC QUALIFIERS (15)
Team | RPI | SOS | T1-20 | T21-40 | TOP WIN | LOSSES 40+ |
---|
North Carolina | 1 | 4 | 10-0 | 4-0 | Boston College (2) | --- |
Northwestern | 3 | 12 | 6-2 | 5-0 | Maryland (8) | --- |
Florida | 5 | 15 | 5-2 | 4-0 | Johns Hopkins (11) | --- |
Yale | 6 | 13 | 5-2 | 5-1 | Princeton (4) | --- |
James Madison | 9 | 27 | 1-4 | 6-0 | Florida (5) | --- |
Navy | 14 | 30 | 2-2 | 3-2 | Virginia (7) | Jacksonville (44) |
UMass | 16 | 54 | 0-1 | 3-2 | Holy Cross (33) | --- |
Stony Brook | 18 | 36 | 0-2 | 4-2 | Drexel (23) | --- |
Denver | 24 | 35 | 2-2 | 2-1 | Stanford (11) | Louisville (48) |
Liberty | 39 | 53 | 0-3 | 1-1 | Richmond (37) | Jacksonville (44), Louisville (48) |
UAlbany | 49 | 42 | 0-4 | 0-3 | Bryant (46) | UMass Lowell (54) |
Fairfield | 52 | 73 | 0-0 | 0-5 | Boston U (63) | Hofstra (57), Mount St. Mary's (64) |
Mercer | 53 | 60 | 1-1 | 0-3 | Clemson (17) | Jacksonville (44), Vanderbilt (58), Furman (65) |
LIU | 67 | 104 | 0-1 | 0-0 | Iona (87) | 5 losses vs. 40+ |
Akron | 87 | 123 | 0-0 | 0-0 | Robert Morris (90) | 7 losses vs. 40+ |
North Carolina will be well rested whenever it faces its NCAA second-round opponent as the No. 1 seed … Northwestern is in the same camp as UNC, but as the No. 3 seed … Florida fell behind three early against Arizona State but pounded a 19-3 run to claim the Big 12. The Gators should be a top five seed.
Yale had the most impressive weekend by beating a game Penn team and dominating Princeton on the road for the Ivy League title and a presumable seed … James Madison won its first American Athletic Conference tournament trophy. The Dukes will be on the road with a likely destination to Virginia, Maryland or North Carolina … Navy answered any questions about its at-large candidacy by ripping off the Patriot League title.
Stony Brook had to battle a desperate Drexel squad to claim the CAA title. The Seawolves will be sent on the road to one of five possible sites … UMass had no problem beating second-seeded Saint Joseph’s to claim its final Atlantic 10 tournament title, its first since 2021 … Denver made sure to not chance its at-large profile by winning the Big East. The Pios will likely be flying to Florida.
Liberty is in the big dance for the first team in team history by winning the ASUN over defending champion Coastal Carolina … UAlbany, as the No. 3 seed, dispatched top-seeded Bryant in the America East to return to the NCAA tournament after missing out in 2024 … Fairfield made easy work of Iona in the MAAC final and claim the title that eluded them last year.
Mercer doubled up High Point to claim yet another Big South title. The Bears are the only team that can drive to Gainesville, so expect a rematch with Florida … LIU withstood the thunderstorms Saturday night to beat host Stonehill and lift the NEC trophy … Akron is another newcomer to the NCAA tournament, as it beat host Robert Morris in an overtime thriller. The Zips are one of two teams that can drive to Evanston, so expect them to play Michigan on Northwestern’s Martin Stadium.