Skip to main content
Ohio State lacrosse goalie Caleb Fyock directs traffic during a game at Johns Hopkins

USILA Announces 2025 Division I All-Americans, Award Winners

May 22, 2025
USA Lacrosse Magazine Staff
John Strohsacker

The United States Intercollegiate Lacrosse Association (USILA) announced its All-Americans and individual award winners for the 2025 Division I men's lacrosse season Thursday.

CJ Kirst unsurprisingly won the Lt. Raymond J. Enners Award as the national player of the year. The Cornell superstar and PLL No.  1 draft pick is expected to add the Tewaaraton Award to his haul later this month.

Two Ohio State players earned awards in recognition of a historic season that came to an abrupt end in the first round of the NCAA tournament.

A short-stick defensive midfielder, meanwhile, received the Lt. j.g. Donald MacLaughlin Jr. Award as the nation's top midfielder.

Award Winners

Lt. Raymond J. Enners Outstanding Player of the Year
CJ Kirst, Sr., A, Cornell

Lt. Col. JI Turnbull Outstanding Attackman
Jackson Eicher, Sr., A, Army

Lt. j.g. Donald MacLaughlin Jr. Outstanding Midfielder
Aidan Maguire, Jr., SSDM, Duke

William C. Schmeisser Defensive Player of the Year
Shawn Lyght, So., D, Notre Dame
Bobby Van Buren, Sr., D, Ohio State

Ensign C. Markland Kelly Jr. Outstanding Goalie
Caleb Fyock, So., G, Ohio State

ALL-AMERICANS

First Team
A — CJ Kirst, Sr., Cornell
A — Jackson Eicher, Sr., Army
A — Coulter Mackesy, Sr., Princeton
A — Sam King, Sr., Harvard
A — Chris Kavanagh, Sr., Notre Dame
M — Sam English, Gr., Syracuse
M — Andrew McAdorey, Sr., Duke
M — Hugh Kelleher, Sr., Cornell
SSDM — Aidan Maguire, Jr., Duke
SSDM — Christian Mazur, Sr., Army
LSM — Christian Fournier, Sr., Army
FO — Brady Wambach, So., North Carolina
D — Shawn Lyght, So., Notre Dame
D — Bobby Van Buren, Sr., Ohio State
D — Will Schaller, Jr., Maryland
D — AJ Pilate, Sr., Army
G — Caleb Fyock, So., Ohio State

Second Team
A — Joey Spallina, Jr., Syracuse
A — Aidan Carroll, Gr., Georgetown
A — Ryan Goldstein, So., Cornell
M — Evan Plunkett, Jr., Army
M — Willem Firth, So., Cornell
M — Benn Johnston, So., Duke
SSDM — Ben Ramsey, Sr., Notre Dame
SSDM — Eric Kolar, Jr., Maryland
LSM — Will Donovan, Jr., Notre Dame
FO — John Mullen, So., Syracuse
D — Ty Banks, So., Georgetown
D — Colin Mulshine, Sr., Princeton
D — Charlie Johnson, Jr., Duke
G — Logan McNaney, Gr., Maryland

Third Team
A — Owen Duffy, So., North Carolina
A — Matt Traynor, Sr., Penn State
A — Owen Hiltz, Sr., Syracuse
M — Mikey Weisshaar, Jr., Towson
M — Michael Leo, Jr., Syracuse
M — Chad Palumbo, Jr., Princeton
M — Hunter Aquino, Fr., Penn State
SSDM — Jack Pilling, Jr., Richmond
SSDM — Carter Rice, Sr., Syracuse
FO — Henry Dodge, Jr., Vermont
LSM — Ben Wayer, Sr., Virginia
LSM — Jack McDonald, Gr., Maryland
D — Jayson Singer, Sr., Cornell
D — Pace Billigns, Gr., Michigan
D — Hunter Smith, Jr., Richmond
G — Sean Byrne, Jr., Army

Honorable Mention
Click here for the full list.