Yale men’s lacrosse coach Andy Shay responded to an interview request with a text message at 6:13 a.m. on a Monday.

Shay always tells it like it is. The prompt — a conversation about the nationally ranked Bulldogs’ prospects for the 2027 season — elicited a surprising answer.

“This team currently doesn’t work hard enough to be considered a top-20 team,” he texted.

Despite having many key players back from last year’s 9-6 team that made its first NCAA tournament appearance since 2023, Shay later said he had not seen the progress through the fall to support a high preseason ranking for the Bulldogs. 

“We hope to be there,” he said. “But we feel like we’ve got a long way to go.”

A year ago, Yale was not in the preseason top 20. The Bulldogs started 3-4, their first two losses coming by a combined 16 goals. Their offense was relying on freshmen and sophomores. They were so young that Shay had joked when they travel, “They need car seats and permission slips.” 

But they grew up. Beginning with a one-goal win over Cornell, Yale won six straight games to reach the Ivy League tournament before losing to Princeton in the semifinals. The Bulldogs earned an at-large spot in the NCAA tournament and led Syracuse at halftime before falling 16-15 at the JMA Wireless Dome.

“Our guys, they knew they were a work in progress the entire year,” Shay said. “But then they end up slowly getting better. Late in the year, they kind of started to click a little bit offensively. Now we’ve got to do that on the defensive end this year.”

Yale’s offense returns its top six scorers, led by junior Connor Gately and last year’s Ivy League Rookie of the Year, Sean Grogan.

Peter Moynihan and Cole Cashion lead a talented group in the midfield. Anthony Annunziata will fill the captain role. Long-stick middies Luke Michalik and Gaetano Cicotello return, as does the rope unit. Faceoff specialists Nick Wehmeyer and Ben Cuomo are both back, though Wehmeyer missed fall ball after having surgery on an injury he played with all spring. 

At the defensive end, Ben Friedman returns in goal after making double-digit saves in 10 games in his first season as the starter.

The Bulldogs are hoping he’s not called on to make even more this year. Because what’s in front of Friedman is what keeps Shay awake at night. Close defensemen Patrick Pisano, Konrad Miklaszewski and Eric Platten all graduated.

“It's not like a little bit, a few guys here and there,” Shay said. “It's your entire close defense and it has a huge effect.”

Yale evaluated several returning defensemen and was even prepared to give starting roles to first-year players, but even that plan became complicated when freshmen Caleb McDowell and Riley Syverson sustained injuries in the fall.

“We're working through it,” Shay said. “We've converted a couple of guys, so hopefully that makes us better in the long term.”

Shay doesn’t see a ton of runway to figure it out. While most programs can begin practices after the first week of January, the Ivy League can’t start until Jan. 25. The fall was an important starting point, but Shay had hoped to be further along in sorting out the defense.

“It's been a challenge for sure,” Shay said. “There's not a lot of experience back there. Every practice they're going against an offense that's got a lot of experience. We're just hoping that they continue to work hard and get better. But it has been a work in progress.”

Shay also is concerned that the offense has had it a little too easy in practice. He doesn’t want players developing bad habits against a work-in-progress defense. And he’s worried about how much the Bulldogs will have to lean on their scorers during the season.

“It's scary if we don't win a ton of faceoffs,” Shay said. “I never like to go into a season relying on your offense, because faceoffs are going to matter.”

Yale barely got by Stony Brook and lost to Providence in the fall. Shay has had other teams struggle during fall ball and turn out fine. Notably, the defending NCAA champion Bulldogs of were humbled by their own alumni in the fall of 2018. Still, they made it back to the national championship game in 2019.

“This is standard panic,” Shay said.

Last year, the concern was about an offense that was relying on young, inexperienced players. They developed into the 13th-ranked scoring offense in the country after averaging 14.5 goals per game over the final eight games on their way to the NCAA tournament.

The Bulldogs need to see similar growth from this year’s defense.

“I’ve got to be a better coach and we’ve got to get them ready. Right now, we're not there,” Shay said. “Hopefully we can recover if we stub our toe early, but we are not the team that people think we are yet.”

  • Always on